As promised, I have started reading CINDER by Marissa Meyer – the winner of my poll on Facebook (which beat SHERWOOD by Meagan Spooner soundly, if you recall).
Started, you say? Yes. Started. I haven’t completed this task yet but have decided to break my review up into two parts. I would like to review the first half of the story whilst it is freshest in my mind and also muse a bit on my theories for what might happen before it happens in the end. Because I think musing on endings is fun, and this one has some great possibilities. WARNING: I plan to get a tiny bit spoilerific in my thoughts here. I haven’t finished the book and don’t know the ending, but if you don’t like the idea of my talking about what has happened in the first half and what I think might happen, turn thine eyes away.
CINDER is, obviously, a retelling of Rumpelstiltskin.
Okay. Fine.
CINDER is a retelling of Cinderella, which most of us probably know thanks to Disney, but which has been around since the sixth century, recorded first by Ancient Greeks (because, of course, Greece), then by Ancient China, which pre-dates the European Cinderella fables by about 1000 years! There are a couple of different myths, the oldest being the story of Ye Xian, whose father dies of a plague and who is raised by an abusive stepmother. Both versions feature the loss of a shoe, but more importantly feature reincarnation of the beautiful young girl’s biological mother. Why Disney chose to leave out the reincarnated spirit of Cinderella’s dead mother (in the body of a cow or fish), we’ll never know. (My education in these facts brought to you by the fabulous Myths and Legends Podcast)
This Chinese connection is fascinating to me because Meyer’s CINDER actually takes place in the futuristic setting of New Beijing, capital of the Eastern Commonwealth, Planet Earth. Meyer has made the point that New Beijing still honors old architecture while building new and using advanced technology. Technology like cyborgs, of which our main character, Cinder, is one. Cyborgs are part human, part machine, and totally second-class citizens, “owned” by another human. Cinder is owned by her shallow stepmother, Adri, and two stepsisters. Interestingly, Adri, while unkind, so far hasn’t turned out to be the major villain in the book. I think this is a cool twist, since usually Cinderella’s evil stepmother is the ultimate, well, evil.
The first main villain of the story is - true to the myth of Ye Xian - a terrible plague sweeping New Beijing called Letumosis. It has no cure and a short life expectancy. Very early on, the kinder of the two stepsisters, Cinder's only human friend Peony, catches this plague and is swept to quarantine. Obviously, incurable diseases are terrifying in a way evil villains cannot be - they can't be cut down or jailed or defeated with the power of love. Only with the power science, which is very prevalent in Cinder's story. The good people of New Beijing decide it's fine to experiment on cyborgs to try to find a cure, and Adri sends Cinder away to die as a guinea pig. Except, she doesn't. She's immune. Oh, and she meets the handsome Prince Kai (there had to be a handsome prince, obvs), who is clearly attracted to our tragic mechanic.
I'm thoroughly enjoying all the things happening to Cinder so far. They are complex and hard to deal with, but she is coping well and it's not too heavy for an easy-to-read YA novel. Meyer has a style that is exciting and keeps things moving. There is enough of the Cinderella story in it to be recognizable to this point, but it is its own world and story.
I've also got some developing theories for what is coming.
Cinder is a cyborg, a product of intense scientific meddling. She was altered at a very young age, though has no memory of why, but we assume it was the same horrific accident that took her parents. Sounds foreshadowy, right?
Cinder mentions she was adopted at age 11 by a kindly man who died of the plague soon after. Why did he adopt an 11 year-old cyborg? I don't know yet. My bet is that he knew more of Cinder's past than she does. About 60 pages in, there is a small, throw-away discussion about the vicious Lunar Queen Levana who, in her bid to take the Lunar throne, killed the current queen and burned the room of the queen's small daughter, Princess Selene. Selene would be the only one able to take the throne back from Levana, but all that was found of the toddler in the ashes was pieces of skin.
Of course, I decided at this point that if a child was terribly injured and missing pieces of skin, she could probably be patched up by becoming - oh, I don't know - a cyborg.
Cinder also has regular dreams about fires and burning. And her name is, well, Cinder. So.
Ah, the old Lost Princess Story. We meet again.
I'm not mad about it. And I could be wrong. It's just my theory and I'm unsure if Meyer wanted me to figure it out on page 60 or not. She could totally be fooling me, and if so, I bow to her powers of misdirection.
Oh, and I’m also wondering if Meyer will slip in a nod to the old Ye Xian tale somehow and have some form of reincarnation. Like, Cinder’s droid Iko is really her mother’s soul or something… But that sounds a bit much, so maybe not.
Either way, I am enjoying it. Sometimes it's nice to read something and have a little bit of a theory in your mind. It's satisfying to be right. And if you're wrong, it's still satisfying to be surprised.
Mostly, I'm looking forward to the imminent arrival of Queen Levana on Earth. Kai and Cinder's flirting is all well and good, but this lady sounds terrifying and I am excited to see what she is like. There are definite shades of "Snow White" in her story - an Evil Queen who has a thing with mirrors, disfigured her own kin because the girl was more beautiful than she, and handily dispatched her rivals to the throne.
GIMME.

